With so many NFL teaching positions vacant, one identify retains popping up because the golden goose of 2022: Sean Payton. The previous Tremendous Bowl-winning New Orleans Saints coach is on the verge of returning to the league, and with it comes the hype and expectation that he can carry rapid success to the ailing franchise.
Payton is nice, make no mistake, and his return to the league after the break comes on the good time for him. Many of the high coordinators are both nonetheless within the playoffs, have taken on head coach positions, or would favor to remain of their present organizations to attempt to hold preventing for the championship, ready to see if different positions change into accessible sooner or later.
There are much more vacancies than sure coaches for the time being, and this vacuum has led to Payton turning into the most well liked identify in teaching rumors. To complicate issues, he nonetheless has a contract with New Orleans, and any workforce that needed Payton must spend vital draft capital to land him. Supposedly the Saints need nothing greater than a mid-round 1 choose, which might imply both a superb workforce could be pressured to surrender a choose within the first spherical after which some – or a rebuilding workforce that believes all it wants is an effective coach, and that is extra vital than going a unique route and doubtlessly getting a franchise-defining participant.
Let’s sluggish all of it down for one second. Is Sean Payton actually value it? We all know his resume, however is that sufficient to make the workforce significantly take into account giving up their fortune for a well-established coach reasonably than in search of next-generation expertise?
Sean Payton case
If you wish to rent a Tremendous Bowl successful coach, you will not discover anybody else. Additionally, there’s one thing to be stated for bringing in somebody with expertise.
The NFL has modified lately to see many groups determined to win now. Monetary ramifications, new possession, and the top of an period for a lot of elite quarterbacks have led to an arms race – which was justified by Tampa Bay’s Tremendous Bowl win in 2021 adopted by the Rams final season.
To change into a win now workforce, it’s essential encourage the religion of veteran free brokers who see your group as a spot the place they’ll get their ring earlier than crusing away into the sundown. This requires expertise, confirmed route and, maybe most significantly, a coach who will get the job performed not solely on the pitch but additionally in recruiting gamers.
This makes a workforce like Denver an apparent potential touchdown spot. In the event you actually consider that Russell Wilson can get the juice out of you, there’s most likely no higher option to get this workforce out of the basement and again into competitors.
I will be sincere, that is the very best argument I can give you – as a result of a win-win state of affairs is the one one that basically is sensible.
The case towards Sean Payton
Are we actually positive Payton can have the identical impression with out Drew Brees? How, actually, actually positive? As a result of it is higher to have a solution to this query earlier than you make investments the cash wanted to hire a Payton and quit the selection required to take action.
Payton and Brees had been linked for the overwhelming majority of their careers, and the one vital success they’d was of their collaboration with one another. There merely is not sufficient concrete proof to say whether or not Brees thrived on Payton’s system or whether or not Payton benefited by having one of many best quarterbacks of all time for 15 years.
It’s objectively true that the Saints underperformed Payton, particularly within the playoffs. We’re speaking a couple of 15-year run within the NFC that did not require going by means of Tom Brady and New England because the AFC needed to undergo – and but New Orleans turned it into one Tremendous Bowl win and solely two NFC championship appearances. The remainder had been in flames within the Wild Card or Divisional rounds, regardless of big common season information.
Successful a lot of video games is good, however there is a totally different stage of management that comes with Payton as a senior coach in want of big compensation than because the doe-eyed assistant he was when he took over as Saints at 42.
In fact, that is earlier than we get to the elephants within the room.
Being concerned in a 2010 prescription drug controversy that has but to be finalized in courtroom
- Suspended in 2012 for BountyGate
- Roughly saving the Saints after one failed season with out Brees, which can have been half of a bigger plan to affix Tom Brady in Miami
- Film theme house workforcewhat the hell was
It is a number of baggage while you put your complete future on the workforce.
So… is Payton value it?
Look, it nonetheless relies upon. Like I stated, in case you’re the Broncos or possibly even the Cardinals, a workforce that appears moderately near rivalry and also you simply really feel such as you want a coach to place all of it collectively, then possibly.
It perplexes me that groups just like the Texans and the Panthers appear to be all for Payton. Each require a whole overhaul, and it will get lots more durable when you need to forgo assets simply to get a coach.
More often than not, we have seen coach swaps have had blended outcomes. Jon Gruden helped the Buccaneers win the Tremendous Bowl and Invoice Belichick promoting the Jets shall be remembered eternally – however what about Herm Edwards for the Chiefs? Mike Holmgren to the Seahawks? Simply because success has been achieved in a single place does not imply it is going to carry over – and conditions like Andy Reid are the exception, not the rule.
In any case, it’s a very watch out for the client. Sean Payton is a very good soccer coach, however there are many good soccer coaches who do not require you to surrender draft capital.